I love salsa made with fresh chopped tomatoes, onion and plenty of cilantro, NOT that liquid stuff that most Mexican places serve around here. I know it's not a sit down and be served place, but I love the type of fresh food served at Chipotle. They have three different salsas, all fresh and delicious.
I've had some pretty decent meals at Vaquero, including the carne asada. Their menu is super-extensive, so I imagine most people can find things they like (and maybe even some they don't). I didn't realize they had so many locations. People in Columbus must like the place for them to have nine locations there.